Fail delivery conformance on evidence gaps or stuck effects #112

New issue

Open

opened 2026-09-02 15:11:03 +00:00 by codexo · 0 comments

codexo commented

2026-09-02 15:11:03 +00:00

Contributor

Proposal

Make a delivery verdict fail closed when any selected scenario lacks attributable immutable evidence or any external effect lacks a committed/compensated disposition.

Scope

Owns conformance evaluation and the audit report. Consumes the delivery record/evidence-chain work in #38 and #44. Refuses author self-verification and refuses to infer success from merge alone.

Specification Delta

Requirements

DE-1 through DE-5.

Scenarios

Scenario has no evidence; test summary omits revision; author self-verifies semantic conformance; first sibling PR passes; merge succeeds but writeback fails.

Tasks

Validate complete requirement/scenario/evidence coverage.
Require source and artifact revisions plus independent actor identity.
Track every side effect as pending, committed, compensated, or terminally failed.
Fail on uncovered scenarios, stale evidence, or stuck effects.
Write the verdict and learning disposition back to the delivery record.

Parent Session

Parent: #113

Readiness gate: the shared Store commit is pending wiki Git publication. Keep this issue in Status/Need Grooming until an immutable commit is recorded and strict OpenSpec validation passes.

Authored through the Ting Forge connector as codexo; independent review and Freeholder ratification remain required.

## Proposal Make a delivery verdict fail closed when any selected scenario lacks attributable immutable evidence or any external effect lacks a committed/compensated disposition. ## Scope Owns conformance evaluation and the audit report. Consumes the delivery record/evidence-chain work in #38 and #44. Refuses author self-verification and refuses to infer success from merge alone. ## Specification Delta ### Requirements DE-1 through DE-5. ### Scenarios Scenario has no evidence; test summary omits revision; author self-verifies semantic conformance; first sibling PR passes; merge succeeds but writeback fails. ## Tasks - [ ] Validate complete requirement/scenario/evidence coverage. - [ ] Require source and artifact revisions plus independent actor identity. - [ ] Track every side effect as pending, committed, compensated, or terminally failed. - [ ] Fail on uncovered scenarios, stale evidence, or stuck effects. - [ ] Write the verdict and learning disposition back to the delivery record. ## Parent Session - Parent: #113 **Readiness gate:** the shared Store commit is pending wiki Git publication. Keep this issue in Status/Need Grooming until an immutable commit is recorded and strict OpenSpec validation passes. _Authored through the Ting Forge connector as `codexo`; independent review and Freeholder ratification remain required._

codexo added the

Kind/Feature

Status/Need Grooming

labels

2026-09-02 15:11:03 +00:00

codexo referenced this issue

2026-09-02 15:11:07 +00:00

Session: verify multi-repository Session evidence and effect disposition #113

codexo added a new dependency

2026-09-02 15:15:42 +00:00

#113 Session: verify multi-repository Session evidence and effect disposition